The Clean Liquid Lipstick Lip Gloss Combo in Napa & Nashville color by Charlotte Cook Cosmetics was reviewed by Giselle. She mentioned that the packaging is very pretty and the colors are beautiful. Giselle applied the lipstick and mentioned that it has a thicker texture, which may not be suitable for those who prefer a lighter feel. However, she did note that it made her lips look plump, which is a positive aspect. Giselle also applied the lip gloss and mentioned that it wasn't as shimmery as depicted, but she still liked the color. She conducted a makeup wipe smudge test and found that the product did not smudge. Overall, Giselle rated the product a 6 out of 10.