Taylor reviewed the Bye Panda Eyes! Vol. Def. Masc. by Essence and found it to be an excellent choice for smudge-proof volumizing and defining mascara. The application was easy and the mascara was not clumpy. The mascara made Taylor's eyelashes look bolder, bigger, and fuller. After a smudge test, nothing came off. Taylor highly recommends this mascara for anyone looking for something that is smudge-proof, volumizing, and defining.