The reviewer, Sharese, reviewed the Essence Bye Bye Panda Eye mascara in a video. She mentioned that she liked the name of the product but was not impressed with the application. She noticed little flakes or build-ups on her lashes, which made it look like it was flaking. While the mascara claimed to be smudge-proof and volumizing, Sharese did not experience any volumizing effect on her lashes. Overall, she concluded that the mascara did not meet her expectations and she would not recommend it. Despite its catchy name, the mascara failed to deliver on its promises of smudge-proof and volumizing properties.