You know that I've given the opportunity to try Pat McGrath, I was gonna go for a liner too, come on! Now, I didn't realize that this was the brown one when I got it, not gonna lie, the shade is black coffee. I was impressed off the bat with the tip though, and application-wise, I was happier with the color. It was a darker brown, I was really excited to use it, and obviously, you can see it really didn't smudge, and no real transfer, so went into this stoked. And first one, went pretty well. It wasn't until I got to the second wing that I feel like the pen was kind of pulling product off of itself a little bit. I don't love felt tip liners, I was hoping that this was gonna be an exception. For the price, I struggled a little bit too much with it, like trying to activate it, trying to get that straight tip, would not repurchase.

I gave this Pat McGrath liner like an iffy review when I first got it. It's a shade Extreme Black Coffee. The name made me think of black flag. That's part of why I bought it. By the time that I tried this, I thought that it kind of like wasn't pigmented or precise enough. But I did this whole liner with it today. As you can tell. It is nice and pigmented and silky. I did not realize that it was brown when I ordered it. But this has definitely gotten me into brown liner. I typically never stray from black. But it's nice to change it up every once in a while. And this is a lot nicer than I originally gave it.

i know i look crazy right now but i'm a pat mcgrath stan and liquid eyeliner to me has always been kind of weird because i was always back and forth between felt tip and a brush this is a felt tip and it's a really good felt tip because a lot of times when i use felt tips it bends too much and then i have this like wonky line that's thicker in one spot and thinner in the other so i'm just gonna show you i'm gonna pull back my eyes it's like boom i already did this eye but like it's amazing and i really like it it lasts all day pat mcgrath she's done it again

Pat McGrath Labs Perma Precision Liquid Eyeliner: Xtreme black coffee 0.034 oz Video Reviews