The reviewer, Alyssa, tried the Palladio liquid eyeliner in shade black. Despite a minor smudging issue, she overall liked the product. Alyssa mentioned that she would have preferred a brush tip instead of the felt, as she finds it difficult to use. However, she appreciated the shaker in the eyeliner to ensure consistent formula application. While she couldn't fully assess its smudge-proof claim, Alyssa gave the eyeliner an eight and a half out of 10. Overall, the Palladio liquid eyeliner in black color seems to be a promising product, with its smudge-proof potential and convenient formula mixing feature. However, a brush tip option would enhance its usability.
