Charisse received the bye panda eyes! vol. def. masc. by essence and was impressed with its performance. She found it to be smudge-proof and defining, giving her long and perfect eyelashes. Charisse even tried it on her bottom lashes and was equally satisfied. She highly recommends this mascara and emphasizes its ability to lengthen lashes. The product's name, Bye Bye Panda Eyes, suggests that it effectively prevents smudging. While the review does not mention any drawbacks, it is important to note that individual experiences may vary. Overall, Charisse's positive experience and recommendation make the bye panda eyes! vol. def. masc. by essence a promising choice for those seeking a defining and long-lasting mascara.