The That's My Jam Eye Shadow Palette by Too Faced is a visually appealing product with cute packaging and great color options. The reviewer, Sean, was initially drawn to the pastel palette and found the colors to be impressive. However, they noted that some shades appeared darker than expected, making it more suitable for a smoky look with a pop of color. The pigmentation of the shadows was praised, with the shimmery purple shade standing out for its bluish purple shimmer. Overall, Sean believes the product is of high quality and recommends it for those looking to achieve a smoky look with a touch of vibrant color.