The Bye Panda Eyes! Vol. Def. Masc. by .essence. was reviewed by Tia in a video review. Tia iniTially rated the mascara a 6 but later changed it to an 8. She liked how it volumized her eyelashes on both the top and bottom. Tia mentioned that she didn't apply too much on the bottom lashes but still liked the overall look it gave. She highly recommended the mascara and expressed her satisfaction with the product. Overall, the mascara seems to be effective in providing volume to the lashes and is smudge-proof, as the name suggests. However, further information about the mascara's longevity and ease of application would be helpful.