Share this

Our Top 10 Liquid Eyeliners for Show-Stopping Looks

Sep 28, 2022
May 25, 2023

Eyeliner is a key part of any eye makeup look. It adds depth to your look, makes your lashes appear fuller, and augments your eye’s natural shape. It’s no surprise that many makeup lovers are fiercely loyal to their eyeliner of choice, whether they swear by eyeliner pencils, gel eyeliner, or liner pens.

Applying liquid eyeliner is scary for rookies, but if you ask us, it’s the best choice for someone who wants a bold and precise look. In the right hands, a liquid eyeliner pen results in sheer artistry. But of course, you’ll need the best eyeliner for that perfect wing or fine line.

We have a wide range of excellent liquid eyeliners here on Flip, with options for eyeliner beginners and experts alike. Look at a few of our favorites below — you might find your new go-to makeup tool.

Share this
Woman in yellow turtleneck shirt putting eyeliner
Table of Contents

1. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner

Make eyeliner the easiest part of your makeup routine — this liquid eyeliner was designed with a flexible tip for precise application you can easily control. Developed with plant-derived ingredients, this liner is gentle enough for sensitive eyes. But don't be fooled by the natural ingredient list: This eyeliner is made to stay in place. Honest Beauty’s highly pigmented, bold color formula glides on seamlessly to create a perfect-looking, satiny smooth line that stays on your lid for up to eight hours — no flaking, budging, or smudging.

2. Eyeko Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

Meet Eyeko’s darkest liquid eyeliner yet. Inspired by traditional calligraphy, this tool makes winged eyeliner effortless, no matter your skill level. Smooth, fluid, single-stroke color glides on and lasts for an all-day finish without fading. Plus, this vegan liner promises controlled application with a precision brush tip.

3. Babe Lash Enhancing Liquid Eyeliner

Babe Lash’s Enhancing Liquid Eyeliner is a smudge-proof, felt tip liner for ultimate precision that enhances your lash line. The pointed felt tip delivers a clean, precise, and dramatic line while the peptide-rich formula conditions your skin and lashes.

4. Pacifica Eye Love Liquid Eyeliner

It’s always love at first sight for everyone who uses this lasting, charcoal-based liquid liner. Rock a dramatic wing or make your eyes pop with the perfectly defining fine tip liner. Lightly pull across the lash line as close to your lash roots as possible. Extend past the eye for a winged tip.

5. theBalm Cosmetics Schwing Liquid Eyeliner

This liquid liner is a home run. Built with a uniquely thin and tapered felt-tip applicator, Schwing gives you careful control over subtle strokes and bold lines. Create winning looks with this rich, matte-black finish that won’t smudge, flake, or take forever to dry. Plus, Schwing comes in a compact and pocket-friendly package.

6. Too Faced Better Than Sex Liquid Eyeliner

This cutting-edge liquid eyeliner is the easiest you'll ever use, created to produce a sharp, fluid, smudge-proof line every time. The combination of Too Faced’s easy glide 24-hour waterproof formula and the innovative dual-fiber brush makes this eyeliner so amazing it's “better than sex.”

7. KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

This award-winning, waterproof liquid eyeliner offers all-day wear and an inky, opaque pigment for creating ultra-precise lines. When applying, use light pressure for fine, exact lines (perfect for creating sharp cat eyeliner wings). Add more pressure to create a thicker, bold eyeliner look. The formula is also great for layering, so you can keep drawing over your lines until you achieve perfection.

8. Pley Beauty Liquid Asset Eyeliner

This colorful liquid eyeliner isn’t for the faint of heart. Ready to go from ingenue to iconic with the flick of a wrist? Pley Beauty designed this liner to be user-friendly and scribble-easy. Beauty newbies can create razor-thin floating liner looks, look-at-me cat eyes, delicate details, or whatever you dream of. 

9. MoxieLash Liquid Magnetic Eyeliner

Get glamorous lashes instantly with pure magnetic eyeliner (no adhesives added). MoxieLash’s waterproof formula keeps magnetic lashes secure for 24 hours without losing hold. The precision tip applicator defines eyes with ease. Stop damaging your lashes with glue and extensions. Just apply, let dry, and click your lashes into place.

10. PYT Beauty Wingman Liquid Liner

This liquid eyeliner offers a water-resistant formula that does not smudge, budge, or smear. The highly pigmented opaque satin formula makes it easy to get precise lines, while the flexible felt tip and ergonomic handle give you complete control. The eyeliner contains nourishing aloe leaf extract, jojoba esters, and vitamin E.


Which liquid eyeliner is best?

Getting the best drugstore liquid eyeliner requires a few important considerations.

First, think about how you plan to use the liner. Do you want a brush applicator (great for thin lines and precise wings) or a felt-tip applicator (helps with easy, smudge-proof application)?

Next, think about what color of eyeliner you want. Black eyeliner is popular, but other options can also enhance your look. White liquid eyeliner helps make your eyes look bigger and more awake, and brown liquid eyeliner gives your eyes definition and depth with a softer overall appearance.

There are also ethical considerations. You may want to search out a brand that’s cruelty free or one that only uses vegan ingredients.

Ultimately, the best liquid eyeliner for you is long-lasting, easy to use, and makes you feel beautiful.

Is it better to use liquid eyeliner?

The best product is always the one that makes you most comfortable and confident. You should never feel like you “have to” use one product over another, no matter what it is.

With that in mind, some perks make liquid eyeliner a cut above other liner types. Liquid liner is more pigmented than the typical eye pencil, so it stands out against your eyeshadow more easily. Liquid eyeliner also lends itself to a more dramatic look, so it’s great for makeup lovers who want to do more intense eye looks. Cat eyes, edgy cut creases, and countless other cool trends simply aren’t possible without the precision that liquid eyeliner provides.

Finally, liquid liner tends to have more staying power than gels or pencils. If you want your look to last from the start of your workday until the club closes, you need the longwear power of liquid liner.

Which liquid eyeliner is easiest to apply?

Liquid eyeliner seems daunting for makeup novices. We get it — the applicator is small, it creates a very noticeable line, and it’s easy to feel like there’s lots of room for mistakes. Luckily, folks who don’t know how to apply liquid eyeliner have plenty of options to help them learn this makeup skill — thanks to liquid eyeliner pens.

No matter the type of eyeliner you want, the Flip community can help you find it. Check out product reviews to see exactly how these liners look on real makeup lovers like you.

Keep reading

download flip app

Scan QR code